basic pumpkin pie
I haven't finished with the Bake Sale. It's just going in a slightly different direction while the holidays are on. I'll post ideas and results here.
Now, on to the main topic: making good pumpkin pie.
When I was a kid, I used to love watching my paternal grandmother make pie. She never used a recipe; she measured everything by handfuls, spoonfuls, and in any clean cup available. Her pies were always, always perfect. The only time I ever heard about a problem was from my mother, who told me once that Grandma wanted to replace the meringue on a lemon pie because ants had eaten half of it. Not the filling, just the meringue. (Mom convinced her to throw the whole thing out, but it took some doing. 'Frugality' was Grandma's middle name.)
Anyway, Grandma made good basic pies--no frills, no surprises. You knew what you were getting, every time. And yet they were never boring, mainly because they were GOOD. They were simple, made from the best ingredients available. Every bite tasted wonderful, even cold. (Nothing beats leftover homemade pie for Black Friday breakfast.)
I've been looking for a good pumpkin pie for a while now. The Libby's label recipe is too pale for me--it's okay in a pinch, but seems too sweet and milky. I also dislike 'chiffon' pumpkin pie, made with gelatin; the texture is supposed to be silky but comes off as granular and a little too slick for my taste.
This recipe is from the Old Farmer's Almanac site. I think this is the closest to my grandmother's style. It's a solid, spicy pie with massive pumpkin presence, but not stodgy or boring. It's delicious on its own or with a little real whipped cream (and if I find out you're using that frozen junk in a tub that's one molecule away from being plastic, I'll know you for a brainless tool of consumerism and you'll NEVER get to eat dinner at my house).
I did make two changes:
1) The original recipe calls for one cup of sugar--a lot for one 9-inch pie. I cut it back to 1/2 cup and it was still plenty sweet. Next time I'll take it down to 1/3 cup. You could also try 1/3-1/2 cup honey, agave or maple syrup in place of the sugar, for less uniform and more unique sweetness. (Molasses is also an option; it has a very strong flavor so be warned, but also makes a lovely luscious dark pie.) If you do choose to try a liquid sweetener, add a little more flour to the mixture--say, 1 1/2 tablespoons instead of just 1.
2) In place of the light cream I used 1/2 cup greek style yogurt, thinned with just a bit of milk. Yogurt gives the pie a subtle tangyness that teams up well with the mellow pumpkin and sweet spices. You could also use sour cream or even buttermilk. If you're going dairy-free, soy, rice or nut milk will work here; the filling will be a bit thinner, but still good.
Also, if your oven tends to run hot, preheat to 375F so your pie won't burn.
My favorite pie crust recipe got lost in the 2006 flood in Fredonia and I'm still trying to replace it, so just use whatever recipe you like. If you don't feel like rolling out a crust, use graham crackers or shortbread cookies to make a crumb crust. It won't detract from the taste at all. (Gluten-free cookies make an excellent crust in place of graham crackers. I make mine from Pamela's shortbread cookies and ghee.) You may blind-bake the pastry crust if you like; that simply means you prick the crust with a fork, then fill the pan with dry beans or a special bead chain to keep the crust from puffing up, and bake it for about 10 minutes. This will help prevent a soggy crust after the filling is added and baked.
The Old Farmer's Almanac Pumpkin Pie
1 cup sugar
1 tablespoon unbleached all-purpose OR gluten-free flour
1/2 teaspoon salt (opt)
1 teaspoon ginger
1 teaspoon cinnamon
1/2 teaspoon nutmeg
dash of pepper
dash of cloves
3 large eggs
1 1/2 cups canned OR cooked and pureed pumpkin
1 cup light cream or evaporated milk
Preheat the oven to 400F. Combine all ingredients and mix until smooth. Pour into a prepared 9-inch pastry or graham-cracker pie shell and bake for 50 minutes. Serve warm with real whipped cream or vanilla-bean ice cream. Serves 6-8.
